The countries said in September that they were exploring an agreement with a non-European Union (EU) country to establish so-called return hubs as part of efforts to accelerate deportations and curb irregular migration.
The agreement is expected to be announced in Vienna following the EU approval of a new Returns Regulation allowing member states to establish deportation centres outside the bloc.
HRW Senior Researcher in the Africa Division Clémentine de Montjoye said the proposed arrangement differed from the United Kingdom’s (UK) previous plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda for processing. However, de Montjoye said concerns raised about the UK proposal remained relevant. “It is extremely concerning to see that once again we are hearing about plans to deport people to Rwanda,” de Montjoye said.
Under the reported plans, people whose asylum applications have been rejected would be transferred to Rwanda.
De Montjoye said the EU’s return hub regulations stated that partnerships could only be concluded with non-EU countries that respected international human rights standards.
Rwanda’s human rights record and the availability of independent monitoring would therefore require scrutiny before any agreement was implemented, according to de Montjoye.
“There is very little opportunity for independent monitoring of Rwanda’s human rights record,” de Montjoye said. “There is very little space for people to express any kind of criticism or to challenge the circumstances that they are in once they are deported to Rwanda.”
De Montjoye said the United States (US) had deported about 20 people to Rwanda during the past year, but little information had emerged about their location, living conditions or welfare.
HRW warned that transferring people to third countries could shift responsibility away from the governments responsible for assessing and resolving asylum cases. “Deportations to third countries more broadly are a way to shift responsibility, and this undermines the good-faith implementation of international human rights law,” de Montjoye said.
De Montjoye said sending people to countries with which they had no connection, without independent monitoring or avenues for accountability, risked serious human rights violations.
HRW identified possible risks including torture, ill-treatment, arbitrary detention, abuses against children, violations of social and economic rights and the denial of an effective remedy.
De Montjoye said any arrangement would need to be legally binding, undergo parliamentary scrutiny and include mechanisms providing effective remedies and accountability for abuses. “Given Rwanda’s human rights record and its response to criticism, we are very sceptical that the necessary monitoring mechanisms can be put in place,” de Montjoye said.
De Montjoye said Rwandan authorities refused entry to the Senior Researcher in 2024 while the UK was pursuing the plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda.
The reported agreement forms part of a broader trend among governments seeking to transfer migrants and asylum seekers to third countries, according to HRW.
De Montjoye cited the UK’s previous proposal and agreements by the US to deport people to several African countries. Some of those affected had been entitled to protections in the US, according to the Senior Researcher. “This does seem to be part of a broader trend by countries to avoid or shirk their responsibilities when it comes to international refugee law or international human rights law,” de Montjoye said.
The arrangements raised questions about the treatment people would receive after deportation and whether effective remedies would be available in receiving countries.
De Montjoye said the EU’s own regulations should prevent Rwanda from being selected as the location of a return hub.
Four of the five countries reportedly preparing to announce the agreement raised concerns about Rwanda’s human rights record during the country’s Universal Periodic Review in January, according to de Montjoye.
The concerns included the independence of Rwanda’s National Human Rights Institution, restrictions on civil society and detention conditions that did not meet international standards. “It is very clear from the EU’s own regulations and obligations regarding international human rights law that sending people to a country with a poor human rights record is in violation of those obligations,” de Montjoye said.
HRW said the possibility of limited independent oversight and restricted access to remedies remained central to concerns over the planned hub.
The organisation has described offshore deportation policies as being designed to inflict human suffering and deter migration rather than fulfil legitimate repatriation objectives.
–ChannelAfrica–
Image: Reuters
